Gabriella Simonian's Berwick Street Brownie is my go-to brownie recipe. I found it in 2013 or 2014 and have made it at least several times a year since. Thank goodness the Wayback Machine saved a copy before the author's blog disappeared! It appears she has moved on to a career as a professional photographer. I wish her well and thank her for all of the effort that went into this delicious recipe.
Changes (few and small)
- 180°C ≈ 355°F; 350°F is fine if your oven doesn't get that precise with the temperature setting.
- I add 1-2 teaspoons of vanilla extract along with the coffee. Clear imitation vanilla extract makes them taste more like box brownies, if that's something you like.
- I mix the cocoa powder into the dry ingredients instead of the stovetop mixture because I feel it gets mixed in more evenly this way.
- Sometimes I put in the walnuts, sometimes I don't. Tastes great either way.
- I cut mine into 24; cutting into 16 makes them pretty huge for my liking.
Variation:
- For the winter holidays last year, a couple of friends sent us a batch of brownies (not this recipe) that contained caramel chips and black walnuts they'd harvested and toasted themselves, and they were really, really good.
- I tried it with the batch pictured and the caramel chips unfortunately melted into the batter. They are much softer than chocolate chips, or at least Hershey's salted caramel chips are. I want little pockets of caramel chip in my brownies!
- Edit 6/24/19: This time I froze the caramel chips first and they stayed intact in the final product. Freeze your caramel chips before adding them to the batter and you'll get little pockets, though I think the caramel flavor is less pronounced this way than melting them into the batter.
- I think this would also work great with peanut butter chips, if that's more your thing.
- Black walnuts have a unique earthy flavor that I really like with chocolate. If you can find them and you like nuts in your brownies, give them a try! My local Hyvee sells them, but you might have even better luck (and get better quality) if you go to a farmers' market. Toasting them before adding to the batter will deepen their flavor.
Some opinions on brownies
I have strong opinions on brownies.
- The best brownies are dense and fudgy. Brownies with cake-like texture are basically chocolate cake. If you want cake, make chocolate cake.
- Interior piece life. I was confused when I saw this brownie pan that ensures you have edges on every piece. Why would anyone want that? Clearly it is not for me. I'd rather have an edge brownie than no brownie, though. I'm not a monster. ;)
- Brownies from boxed mix these days are a joke. When I was a kid they gave you enough mix in the box to fill a 9x13 pan with brownies almost an inch thick. They've kept reducing the amount of the mix in the box so that now they barely bake up to half an inch thick. BOO. They also don't taste very much like chocolate, but they never did so this is less disappointing. Given how they've kept taking things away from it I don't expect them to start now.
- They make clear imitation vanilla extract now, which I have discovered is the one thing about boxed brownie mix that kept me crawling back. Yes, I know real vanilla extract is superior in basically every way but there's something nostalgic and still very much appealing about the aroma of clear imitation vanilla in baked goods to me. (Is it different from the brown imitation vanilla besides the color? It just smells and tastes better somehow.)
RECIPE: The Berwick Street Brownie