Notes:
- Choosing cucumbers
- This recipe works best with pickling cucumbers (they are small, have thin edible skin, and tend to have very small seeds or no seeds). If you can't get those, get English or Persian cucumbers, which have similar characteristics.
- If you can only find regular cucumbers, buy the skinniest ones you can find, peel them (the skin can be bitter and tough depending on the time of year), and cut them in half lengthwise before slicing.
- If the seeds in your cucumbers are big, scoop out the seeds and watery middle part with a spoon. I find it unpleasant to eat this salad with large cucumber seeds in it.
- Substitutions
- Pasta: Other similarly sized, dense, compact shapes of pasta that hold sauce well will work nicely; I have also made it with egg noodles. This salad can be made gluten free if you use gluten free pasta; I found some brown rice rotini that worked great. This salad can also be made vegan if you use pasta that does not contain egg.
- Vinegar: Instead of white vinegar I have used a number of other types (rice vinegar, champagne vinegar, white wine vinegar, apple cider vinegar), all of which I thought were pretty good.
- Canola oil: any other neutral, mild tasting oil will work. I usually use olive oil.
- My grandma's version calls for 1 1/2 cups of sugar but I felt this was too sweet so I reduced it to 1 1/4. You can reduce it further if you like, but for the best flavor I think at least 1 cup is necessary.
- I usually add a large pinch of salt (the original recipe does not call for it).
- I'm working on a version with less water because a bunch of water comes out of the cucumbers the longer it sits and it dilutes the dressing.
- This salad makes great potluck/picnic food.
RECIPE:
Cucumber Noodle Salad
Adapted from my grandma's recipe
Makes about 4 quarts, serves 12-16 people
1 box (16 oz/450 g) rotini noodles
8-10 pickling cucumbers (about 2 lb/900 g)
1 medium sweet onion (about 1/2 lb, 225 g)
Dressing:
1 1/4 cups (2/3 lb, about 300 g) sugar
1 cup (235 ml) water
3/4 cup (175 ml) white vinegar
1 tbsp prepared mustard
1 tbsp canola oil
1 tbsp dry parsley (or 3 tbsp fresh minced)
Cook rotini noodles as directed on package, until on the firm side of al dente. Slice cucumbers about 1/8 inch (~3 mm) thick -- if you have a mandoline slicer, it makes quick work of them. Finely chop or slice sweet onion. Place in a large bowl and set aside while you prepare the dressing.
Whisk all dressing ingredients together in a medium bowl. Pour over noodles, cucumber, and onion and stir to coat. Tastes best when left to stand in refrigerator for several hours before eating.