This is another recipe I bookmarked during early quarantine and finally got the ingredients to make. I was underwhelmed by all the key lime pies I tried in Florida a couple of years ago (ahhh, remember when we could ride planes to go on vacation?) and wanted to see if I could make it better at home.
Notes:
- My filling ended up more brown than most key lime pies I've seen or consumed, and darker than the recipe author's photos. Most recipes have you whip the filling with a hand mixer (a process which aerates it and tends to lighten the color) but this one does not. My sweetened condensed milk may have also been the cause -- it was past its best-by date (but tasted and smelled normal).
- I put an extra egg yolk in the filling (one of the yolks broke during separation). It does not appear that this significantly affected it, except maybe to make it more silky.
- I used the lime zest but not the green food coloring because I don't like the bluish tone of most green food colors (it doesn't match the shade of green that lime is!) plus it was already pretty brown and I didn't want to risk making the color look even weirder.
- Since I don't have a kitchen torch, I used the broiler set to high and put the pie on the second highest rack to toast the meringue. The recipe author is not kidding -- it browns FAST. Mine was very slightly burned after 30 seconds so I'd recommend about 20-25 seconds. Watch it very carefully.
- The meringue wept a LOT once I put it in the refrigerator. The liquid soaked the graham cracker crust and made it hard to get out of the pie plate.
- I ate the pie at room temperature and cold from the fridge, and this pie is decidedly better cold from the fridge. It tastes a little too bitter at room temperature.
Verdict: It's not quite what I was hoping for but it was definitely edible. I'd try it again but I would whip the filling with a hand mixer, and maybe put less sugar in the meringue because I think that's what made it so weepy. My search for a really delicious key lime pie continues, and next time I think I'll try the more traditional whipped cream topping instead of meringue.
---------------